Milburn Review

Milburn Review: A five-year glide path, to reverse the employers’ NIC rise applied by Rachel Reeves, is not good enough. Employers will remain in a situation where they are not utilising full productive capacity, as they remain of the view that it is simply too expensive to hire young people. Alan Milburn, in today’s review of NEETs (Not in Education, Employment or Training), has laid out a series of proposals that, so far, have been well received politically by the Parliamentary Labour Party.

This is not a Government White Paper, so it does not have the formal power of specific legislation to which the Government is committed. Nevertheless, there is broad buy-in for the principles of constraining the welfare state, and more particularly, seeking to break the dependence of young people on welfare. Statistically, there is a 50% chance that an 18-year-old who receives Universal Credit with the additional health component is likely to still be on this benefit 15 years later. It is a moral failing, and for the young person in question, it is a curse.

However, rather than seek to subsidise what could easily be pretend jobs, to the tune of £3,000 or £5,000 for smaller employers, far better than this would be to do away with the NIC rise in employers’ contributions in the first place. This is where the five-year glide path comes in – the Treasury has stated that this is not affordable at this time, hence the delay…

A delay may well suit fiscal conditions now, yet they are effectively being paid for in a waste of the life chances of those young people whom businesses still feel incapable of employing. There is an equity issue: why should a young person aged 20 earn substantially less than somebody doing the same job, aged 21? The minimum wage rate for 18- to 20-year-olds has grown sharply. Between April 2022 and April 2026, the 18-20 rate rose by 59%, from £6.83 to £10.85. Under Labour, it rose 16.3% in April 2025 and a further 8.5% in April 2026, about 26% in total. So it is quite a straightforward trade-off: is it better to earn more in a job you haven’t got, or is it better to be on the employment ladder at the right stage of your career? Because if you fail to get on at the right time…. You might never get on.

This has been a broader problem in UK politics, arguably for decades now – this distinct lack of business experience amongst MPs and the Executive. The Conservative Party certainly is better in its comprehension of business, but even here, modern politicians are too removed from the front line of commerce. Particular mechanics could be considered: Paul Mortimer-Lee  has spoken about rent subsidies to allow young people to move from areas with few job prospects, to areas with jobs. Getting on your bike only works if you have greater chances the other end.

Surely it is a significant step in the right direction, and its success will be shown in fewer young people being outside employment, education or training.

#MilburnReview #NEETS

Unknown's avatar

Author: Damian Merciar

Damian Merciar is Managing Director of Merciar Business Consulting, http://www.merciar.com, a niche business economics consultancy founded in 1998. He has over twenty years experience in the areas of commercial Business Strategy. He is experienced in the transition environments of nationalized to private sector state utilities and the senior practice of commercial management, advisorial consultancy, and implementation. He has carried out policy advisory work for government ministries and been an adviser to institutional bodies proposing changes to government. He holds an MSc Economics from the University of Surrey’s leading Economics department and an MBA from the University of Kent. Also attending the leading University in the Middle East, studying International Relations and Language, for which he won a competitive international scholarship, and has a BA (Hons) in Economic History and Political Economy from the University of Portsmouth. He is currently based in London.

Leave a Reply